Championing Women in the Game of Ice Hockey with Michelle Billingsley
Ever wondered how one woman could change the game of ice hockey? Let me introduce you to our guest, Michelle Billingsley, a true pioneer in women's ice hockey. In our conversation, Michelle narrates her groundbreaking experience of being the first girl to join a boys-only league, an event that ignited her lifelong commitment to promoting and advancing opportunities for girls and women in this sport. From coaching at the NCAA level to co-founding Women's Hockey United, Michelle has continually broken through the ice ceiling and championed the recognition and inclusion of women in ice hockey.
This episode doesn't just stop at Michelle's inspiring story. It's a deep exploration into the progress women's ice hockey has made over the last four decades - and how Michelle has been pivotal in that journey. We debunk the myth that there's no money in women's sports, and put the spotlight on the competitive spirit and skill level in women's hockey. Through citing examples like Jocelyn Lamarau-Davidson, and several other professional women’s players, Michelle makes a compelling case for the need to invest in women's ice hockey.
As we lace up our skates and hit the ice, we take you through the critical issues surrounding girls' participation in sports, and specifically in ice hockey. Michelle shares her insights on the importance of mentorship and coaching at all levels, and the need for increased investment in the sport. We tackle the role of the NHL in promoting girls' hockey and emphasize the significance of creating a lifelong fan experience. If you're keen on the development and growth of women's sports, this episode promises to offer you an in-depth look at the challenges, triumphs, and the road ahead. Join us as we champion the cause of women in ice hockey, one puck at a time.
Text The Our Kids Play Hockey Team!
We're powered by NHL Sense Arena!
NHL Sense Arena, is a virtual reality training game designed specifically to improve hockey sense and IQ for both players and goalies. Experience the next generation of off-ice training in VR with over 100+ drills and training plans curated from top coaches and players.
Use Code "HockeyNeverStops" at Hockey.SenseArena.com to score $50 off an annual plan!
Have A Topic You Want Us To Cover? Let us know!
Please Be Sure To Subscribe & Leave A Review For Us On Apple Podcasts, doing so helps our show grow!
Follow Us On Social Media:
0:08 Hello hockey friends and families around the world, and welcome to another edition of our kids play hockey. I'm Leo Elias with Mike Binelli, and we are joined today by a hockey lifer and someone who has dedicated their life to growing the game. Michelle Billingsley has worked on the ice as an NCAA coach with Newman University and PA and is a credentialed referee who has officiated games at the Olympic, junior and SLEV levels. She has also held many positions off the ice, including the director of hockey operations and the director of hockey at the professional and youth levels. Today, michelle is the co-founder and vice president of Women's Hockey United, whose goal is to build an organization with a diverse group of successful professionals in the sports industry that will cater to further developing female athletes in the sport of ice hockey.
0:52 Summing this all up, michelle is a pioneer in the game of ice hockey and we are excited to have you around today, michelle. Welcome to our kids play hockey. Thank you. Thank you for the introduction and thank you for having me. Ice hockey has been a very exciting part of my life. It's been an exciting journey so. You and I have talked a lot off the camera and I think you have a pretty powerful message. I think you're a pretty powerful person and a shining light for all of us, as someone who's been in the game and really challenged a lot of the norms quote-unquote that we've had in the game over the last 30 years. But it's a common question that we start with Michelle, but it's a necessary one. Tell us, how did you get started in the game? I first was introduced to ice hockey at a very early age.
1:32 My brothers had started playing. My father started them out in the sport. I was born and raised in Bedford, new Hampshire, and there was a Manchester All Boys Ice Hockey League in Manchester, the regional youth hockey association still up and running. They had started playing hockey and of course, I was just someone that they could throw pucks at, shoot pucks at in practice and then when they wanted to practice goal-tenning they needed someone to shoot on them. I, by default, was there. They threw me into it and I fell madly in love with it, just as much as they did. So my parents, who had gone through the Marine Corps and were gender-blinded, thought that would be a great opportunity. Since I loved it, let me join the league and try out and play with my brothers and see how, see what would happen.
2:18 At that time in 1978 there were no girls playing. It was really an all boys league and had been since they started. I was the first to join. I played three years first, my second year of might in two years of squirts where I achieved hat tricks, shutouts. I played center wing goalie, tried everything that I could at anywhere. The coach threw me. I was happy to be there because I just really wanted to belong. It took a couple days, a couple practices. Once the boys found out I was a girl. At first they liked me because of my skills. I blended in with them until they asked me my real name and I told them and they stayed away for a couple more practices.
3:03 But once we played in games together and they saw that I was scoring and helping them in in developing, they actually sort of embraced me and allowed me to develop with them and after the three years they voted me captain for their team, which was really meaningful for me because that was the kids themselves that elected me and it was unanimously so I had an exciting development over the three years and unfortunately at that point the board had been taking a lot of heat from parents. We didn't care for a girl developing with their boy. There really was no concern for me at the point. I came dressed in my gear, so it's not like I had to go into the locker rooms.
3:44 There really wasn't that concern. It was just being on the ice, just being there. For some reason it bothered them. It wasn't even checking, so it wasn't. They were concerned physically. I was actually outscoring them and outplaying them, so it did make sense. So when the board called my parents to inform them that they actually had a vote, the board unanimously voted that I would no longer be allowed to play due to my gender. However, my two brothers, who were equally talented and very well liked by all the boys in the league, they were asked to return, but without me, and my parents made a decision that if we couldn't all play, that we couldn't all return.
4:31 They understood the importance of my brothers being raised with the idea that girls should be playing with boys. With that being said, I played for those three years and there was nowhere for me to go. There was nothing set. It was 1997, 98, where I had the privilege to meet legendary women's basketball coach, pat summit, who did have a hand in passing through title nine. She pulled me aside, we talked about it. She asked me what had happened and pretty much planted the seed of me getting back into girls and women's hockey to pioneer and to help them build opportunities, places and get them access resources and opportunities.
5:16 So that's what I did. I literally got back on the ice, started training and then I got a call from Ben Smith, the Olympic coach, who invited me to train with the US women's Olympic team. At the time was Kami Granado, karen by, shelley Looney, sarah DeCosta just the best women in the world which was an amazing opportunity, and I found it to be very exciting. I trained with them and I had an opportunity to stay with them and play with the national Olympic team. However, I went back and thought a lot about what girls and women's needed to grow.
6:00 It wasn't for me to go and become an Olympic champion. That wasn't going to help them. It would only help me, which would be amazing, but unfortunately, as a youth, I didn't have that dream or goal and passion that I developed and nurtured, so when I got that thrown up there, it wasn't real to me. At the time. I was a mother of three and I thought where could I spend more time helping? And that's where Pat encouraged me to start a women's collegiate program. Michelle, I do want to give a little perspective here for the listening audience, because we're spending 30 years here and I think it's important to look at. When you look at women's hockey, there's several key time periods. You mentioned 1998, so 1998 was a big year for me where I saw women's hockey for the first time and maybe many of our listeners probably don't remember.
6:47 The men's team, which was compiled of NHL players, was horrible that year, horrendous in Nagano, japan, and so I watched women's hockey and we won the gold medal that year in Team USA and I remember for me at that time and I was young, I didn't care it was women, I was glad we won the gold medal and as I got older I didn't realize how monumental of a moment that was, not just for me as a young boy, seeing women as equals in terms of their hockey players, but for women's hockey in general. And again, I think it's important when we look at the perspective here that, even with all of the progress we've made and there's still plenty to be made it's important to remember back to your youth in late 70s, early 80s, where girls were told you can't play period and there was no alternative.
7:31 You talked about hockey in Pennsylvania, in the Philadelphia area, we have one of the premier girls leagues and teams out there and that's a norm today for young girls to grow up and might squirt playing with the boys and then they make the transition over to the girls team. That was not an option in 1981. 1982, there just simply was no hockey. So I think in terms of the progress of the sport, we've made progress. It's a good thing, but it's not enough, right, and we have to continue to do this. And I think for most women's sports, if you are fortunate enough to play collegiate sports, that is the end of the line, right. For lots of different reasons and I want to discuss that too, because I wrote some notes down here, some of the common kickbacks we hear in sport no one watches women's sports.
8:15 There's no money in women's sports and I would say I don't know if that's really the point right. I've never heard a female athlete say I should be paid the same as an NHL player. It's never been the argument. It's just the opportunity to play at a higher level and, as you've said, the professional leagues that are out there, although a little splintered, are progressing the game and we need to move that on. So when someone says to you hey look, nobody watches women's sports, there's no money in women's sports, what is your response to that and for the people listening that want to support what should we be thinking or saying? honestly, I do hear that a lot and I welcome that dialogue. First thing, you know that I would say to them is that was in the past.
8:55 We are growing. We don't have the access, resources and opportunities which will allow us to get more access, but there is a lot of growing. There is a lot of games that there's a lot of selling of tickets, a lot of revenue being generated, not just off of the girls and women's ice hockey from collegiate to professional, but we've also noticed that the NHL teams in the cities that our girls teams and women's hockey teams are in, they're generating a new 35% revenue off of their newly found female fan base, which is us. They're generating money. Let's take a look at that 35%.
9:36 As far as generating money, we're generating it. We're just not getting the it for the most part, the numbers. Now, as far as what I'd like to say is women's hockey has been around since 1890. Let's start there. It's not a new sport I hear it's new. It's a novelty, and I just said no. And sadly and unfortunately, the demise of us growing right now is the lack of the access, resources, investors, donors and media which gives us the media coverage that we so badly needed or do need, and even in the NHL, when they first started in the 1940s, they struggled to get a fan base.
10:19 They didn't have media coverage and then they fizzled. They faded because they had a business structure that did not work. So they picked up a new business structure and started over their media coverage. Once they got investors and the revenue was going towards media coverage, the more media coverage they got, like all men's sports, that's when more investors, sponsors and more revenues coming in and it would give the illusion that there is more fan base, there's more interest. But interestingly, the one thing that they say is we just can't play the sport as fast or strong as the men. Therefore, it's not as entertaining, and I say, first of all, it is more than entertaining.
11:02 Then you give it credit and a lot of people that are showing up to girls and women's hockey aren't just relatives. They're actually ice hockey fans and they're seeing the finesse in the game. They see, although there's no checking, it is very physical and the skill level is actually equal. Let's talk about the olympic hockey history that recently happened in the 2018 pyong chang south korea olympics, where jocelyn lamarot davidson she was the fastest two goals scored by one player. She, of course, played for usa. She scored two goals just in two in six seconds apart.
11:44 In the second period against the oar team. She actually broke a record that was held by carl goren ober, who played on a swedan team. He scored two goals in eight seconds span in 1960. So here's a woman breaking a mail held record as far as two goals scored in uh seconds, and not just by a second, but he was two goals and eight seconds. She was two goals and six seconds. So right there, speed mechanics and skill wise, we're right there. So it's no longer a novel team. I like to point out. We are actually real competitive athletes, just like them, and we're worth investing Right.
12:26 What kind of a coin. At the all star game too, she was putting up an HL speed times, if I'm not mistaken. I remember that as well, exactly yeah, and it's interesting, jocelyn Lamarau she and her sister, monique they put they wrote a book on why girls should play hockey with boys and at their book release in February 2021, they did a ton of promotions, including several podcasts, and Jocelyn had mentioned any even in her master's thesis. Out of 15 players on the US women's Olympic hockey team, 15 of them recommended that girls should play with boys, although one player said yes, no, depending on what the goals of the individual player would be, and I found that interesting.
13:12 Now, this doesn't mean that playing girls only won't get you to the national team. It just discusses how playing with boys helped those that did play with the boys. It just didn't do any research on covering the path to US women's national team. If it's possible, for playing with only girls. But from my experience and from what Lamarau is saying and the other 15 Olympic players, we all developed with boys. The most important developing years were in boys hockey leagues. And she goes on to point out reasons why, which I also agree Skill developing the ice time with the boys. They get 10 plus hours per week when that's what you really need to be a great hockey player.
13:56 The reality is that many clubs girls don't get as many hours as favorite ice times as the boys elite teams and the level of competition the boys hockey provides more options for girls for a free melt player to find a team whose skill level is at the right level for her as she develops. There's also the coaching. The boys clubs tend to have better coaching. So I'll say this to Michelle for me it's always been about a quality of opportunity, right, and that I have a daughter, right. I don't want her to be held back at all. It's funny the other night I was, I took them the public session. My daughter is a couple of years younger than my son and she was chasing him and I saw it on her face. I could see that look on her face of determination that I've seen a lot of athletes and I'm again, I've always been.
14:41 Everything's always been pretty equal for the two of them, but it's, I remember, thinking I just wanted to have the same opportunity that my son has. I think, in terms of professional hockey today, it is not going to pass that a women's professional league will ever rival the NHL today, but the opportunity to play professional hockey is extremely important and the opportunity for a young lady and boy to dream of playing hockey beyond high school or college is a worthy dream to have. It shouldn't just have to end after you're a senior, you're a college hockey. And again, with what we have in professional women's hockey today, as you mentioned, the rosters are very limited and when it comes to investors, I think it just comes down to the product you put on the ice. I think there is an audience for women's hockey.
15:22 I think there is a way to grow the game with women's hockey, and I think that one of the issues we have to continually try and solve is this is that there is no future for women's hockey without men being involved, and the idea is that we want to turn it into hockey. Right Is this? Oh, I play hockey. Not I'm a girl who plays hockey, or I'm a girl on a guys team, I'm a hockey player and I play hockey. And then the opportunity for women to play after college and is what's important to me. So I think your organization is doing a lot to push that correct In terms of just creating the opportunity and making sure that some of the noise of just no one watches that it's just okay. That's not what we're here for. You know what I mean.
16:04 Tell us a little about your organization today and what you're doing today, because I think that's important work as well. Oh, absolutely. I've had the privilege to meet some professional men and women from both the NHL side, the PHF, pwpha side, and they all recognize the same thing they want to help grow women's hockey at the professional level and they don't quite know how to do that. The PHF PWPHA have their people in place. They have solid women running those organizations and they're working really hard at growing that organization and getting the women what they need the access, resources and opportunities.
16:44 They're focusing on growing and expanding. There's so much need for someone to support the girls' youth all the way up to collegiate. So I think for the women's professional hockey organization to have that main responsibility is quite the burden. How are they going to do that? Expand and grow and take care of their women so that they can keep growing? Investors will invest in them. I talked to a lot of investors at what they needed to get the confidence to invest in women's professional hockey. Rob Granato, cammy Granato's brother, has been growing girls' hockey in Chicago, much like I've been doing it in Philadelphia and New Jersey.
17:26 We've grown girls' hockey from youth all the way up to collegiate. We were ready for that next level. We were ready to bring women's professional hockey into our cities, but the women's professional hockey team was not getting the investors they needed to expand into our cities. So we took a step back and we said how are we going to get them to give the confidence to invest in women's professional hockey? And so I reached up to a lot of investors and what they said was my concern is there's that unnatural drop off between college and women's professional hockey. That's a huge market. They're all dropping and so it doesn't give us the confidence that the women's professional hockey league is going to have a pool to recruit from to grow like they need to as quickly as possible.
18:15 So they're just waiting for something to happen. The NHL is waiting for something to happen. Usa Hockey is waiting for something to happen Women's Collegiate programs for investing millions of dollars into their women female student athletes to develop in their women's collegiate programs over those four years. They want to know that their women have somewhere to go and for them to drop off. It's just why are they investing the money in the program? Everyone needs something to happen. So we took a step back and we said we're going to start up the women's hockey United Organization and collectively we're going to pull in former professional women and men coaches who are together will come in and we're going to coach a developing semi-professional women's hockey league.
19:04 We're going to jumpstart that where players and coaches and refs will have a place to go after college, post college, to come in and play in our league. We're going to future. We're going to keep developing them until their professional level. That way, as the PHF and PWPHA also are ready to expand and grow, they have a pool of talent to recruit from and once that's in place, a lot of investors and sponsors said that would definitely give us the confidence to invest money. We can see that those players and coaches and officials are still growing the game.
19:46 Therefore the women's professional leagues will continue to grow. They have a feeding club, much like the men's side had juniors and these semi-professional leagues. Once you had those in place, the NHL picked up a lot of more investors, sponsors. They saw that ladder. So basically we're filling that ladder, that missing piece, and not just filling a place for people to go, but we're pulling in former professional players who know how to coach and mentor those talented women to get them up to that professional level so that they have that opportunity. They have that chance. Their dream can keep alive, they can keep going, stay in the game.
20:28 So it's really important, purposeful. We're really excited we get the right people in place. So right now we're just structuring our inaugural year and looking for investors, sponsors, getting the starter C funding to jumpstart us Once we get going. We've plotted our inaugural year in hotspots for girls and women's hockey where they generated the most revenue. They've had the most fans 10 those games and events in certain tournament times combined with NHL events. The NHL and USA Hockey are excited about our project. They see the importance, they see that we're actually going to have an immediate impact on girls and women's hockey and giving a lot of investors and sponsors that confidence that they need to invest in the women's program.
21:20 So they are all on board to come in and support us. I think too, like with most issues in society, whether it be gender or race or anything, there's no future without us moving forward together as a society, and I think that's one of the pitfalls we fall into when anyone discusses this is it turns into us and them type situation, or an only us situation, whereas it's us versus the world. And the truth is this is that if you want any type of empowerment and you can look at American history to see this to be true in a lot of cases with Martin Luther King Jr and some of the greatest leaders we've had it must be done together. There is no pathway unless we're doing it together.
22:02 Mike, did you want to chime in on this too, bud? Number one, michelle. It's unbelievable, like the commitment level you've given this and your time of your history of hockey, which is great, and certainly everything you talk about is true, right, I think all of the pitfalls and the roadblocks and the pieces we see that could make a successful or an unsuccessful league work are there. I was there, evident, right. I probably fall from the side of having worked in women's professional hockey for a number of years and having been mentored by a lot of women professional hockey players. I think and I don't know, maybe it's just the way I was brought up or the circumstances I just happen to have I find myself never talking about girls and women's hockey as opposed to hockey, and I probably fall into this in a lot of different ways, even in diversity initiatives.
22:52 I think because of the pieces I've been in, I haven't really seen those roadblocks as much as a lot of other regions. So I'm always like I don't know if there's a really good girl player, she's a hockey player and she's beaten the boy she's going to make the team. Now I come from a point of view like where I would, and I've been involved with Teddy Saunders and obviously Sammy Joe and having dinner and events with people that are very involved in women's professional hockey and I think that's the way I would see women's hockey. Kim McCullough, up in Toronto, you look at like having somebody that runs the largest girls hockey program in the world and she would never discuss her hockey program as her girls program. This is the largest hockey program in Toronto and oh, it just happens to be all girls in the conversations I have with her and listening to the people in these kind of venues.
23:41 And even I worked with Colt Norr for two years and he never treated the women's, which is why I think they like him. Is he never differentiated? Oh, you girls can't do this, or you should be doing this. I think the reverse engineering of this. The same struggles happen in junior hockey. Boys play hockey through college and have nowhere to play. Right, and they say I have nowhere to play. I love hockey. Yeah, too bad. You're just not good enough, or does nobody ever want to watch you, or there's no place for you to be. But what can you do? Just to your point, michelle, you can go back into your community. You could go out and find those unbelievable little soccer and field hockey athletes. You could put skates on them and you could organically and grassroots grow the game, and I think that's where I always come in.
24:26 I have been my whole career as a director and a program administrator have always been like the sooner we can get girls hockey to be girls hockey at six, seven, eight years old, the bigger the pool can become. And I don't discount the fact that girls with boys helps in their development. Like I see, six year old girls are physically stronger and better than six year old boys in a lot of cases and I think that's more coordinated, which is weird. Right that you think about where girls are now in the realm of, like, social media and things like that. Like they have more self confidence, they have a little swagger. It's when the boys start hitting puberty and the girls have already matured. These are just facts, right, these are what we see through USA and through hockey Canada, that all of a sudden, that separation becomes bigger, not because of skill level but because of testosterone and just because of the fact that girls are girls.
25:17 Again, I don't want to say it's the wrong way, I just want to say it in a way where the sooner we get girls, in my opinion, the sooner we get girls playing with girls by offering the top level coaching there can be at the earliest levels, whether it be three, four, five, six years old, and building that competitive format. In my world, if I walked into a twin pad facility, I'd see no reason why on this rank there could be 150 girls and on this rank to be 150 boys and on skill sessions there could be 300 together. Like to me, none of that stuff really should be roadblocks and if you're a business owner and an investor and somebody that really wants to see the development of your brand, and as far as I could tell the dads and moms that have girls, their money is worth the same as the moms and dads that have boys.
26:07 So to me is why wouldn't you just want more girls playing Right Now again? But I think statistically and you correct me if I'm wrong but statistically just more boys play youth sports than girls. But and that could change If you can get like I look at soccer and you like to watch a soccer game at six years old. You can't tell. Boys and girls are out there beating the crap out of each other and somebody's out running somebody. But there comes a time for the vast majority of athletes that the girls, physically, are just not in a safe place to play with unskilled boys. That's the fact of you're really skilled women and a really unskilled man that just wants to.
26:49 You see it in boys sports. I see it in high school where a freshman boy is playing against a senior man. They're both males and I'm like I kid shouldn't be playing with that person. It's just not safe. I think it doesn't enhance their development. Now there are there some women. You're talking about the one percenters, right. You're talking about the people that make the Olympics and you watch any, like I was with the Connecticut whale watching these women play and they. I was like they're just good, they're just the best, like they're better than any male I worked with. But there comes a time when we have to understand that if we want to grow the game, we want to grow youth sports and we want women and girls to be a part of that, then we have to figure out a way to get the best women like you back to the six and seven year olds and not worry about the 18 year olds, and just build that pool.
27:38 And that's where I think investors then salivate. I think they say what do you mean? I can have a we call it cradle to grave, right, I can have a cradle to grave customer. I don't have to attach myself to this brand when they're 18 and 19. I can attach myself to this brand when they're for because we call it lifetime value of a fan. That's what we call it, and then an athlete right, your best athletes and your best coaches, male or female, I happen to think, I happen to attract. I try to find like we have a cure, dozedale, you must know her from the riveters. Like she's working in our region where the junior Rangers are. They've invested hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars in girls hockey and not at the professional level which maybe a lot of people say they should be spending more money with.
28:19 Their professionally none of their spend their money and their grassroots efforts by employing these women professional players to work with the five and six and seven and that's how they're making their revenue, right or wrong, and I'm making a revenue through gate receipts they're making the revenue by actually getting their skates on, coming in the rank and being mentors to all these young girls that don't know the difference they look at. They're just dreaming about being professional hockey players. They're just dreaming about being with great, strong women that, yeah, to compete and want to really put themselves in a situation where they're fighting and going for a goal and just like you did with your kids.
28:59 And I coached up a state. So I know Manchester very well and I think, and knowing that region, imagine now when you look at it, some of the best girls in the world are coming out of New Hampshire right now. So when you look at the level of play and where we can be, my vision would be let's get all these great women down to the five and six year olds and there I just think the rest will take care of itself. I think the rest will just organically grow. Will it take longer than maybe some people want? Yeah, but to your point, well, I think it all failed a number of times as well, back in the 1800s, because everybody's like what the hell is? This is the worst sport I've ever seen. Who would watch this?
29:45 It's like a real paradise as it is. Yeah, sports, you know, pro sports are not the revenue monster People think they were, until you start seeing those leagues collide in the late 70s, early 80s. Then they started to grow. But I can certainly see, but I can see the frustration. I can see where these women professional players are up until this year and still many of them, right, have to. They're working as teachers. They get in their car. They got to drive to a rink. They got to go to practice at 1030 at night. They got to go back in their car, drive back to work on the morning, and that's if they're really fortunate to have children. Yet Now you can throw in a whole. I have two kids at home. That's crazy. So but then it's. The next step is the. You have now the opportunity.
30:25 Get back as a youth rink, go out there, get those kids, get into five and six year olds, and then I don't. Giving back is not really the right word because I don't have anybody's obligation to get back. They earned it. But I want to see it grow and you want to see it expand, then somebody needs to be the person that kind of goes back in and builds from the bottom. I do know that a lot of women are going back to their ranks, building at the youth level up. I know Shelly Looney did an amazing job with the New Jersey Colonial girls organization. They're just a powerhouse, from might all the way up to bannums. It's highly popular, more popular than the boys in that rank actually.
31:07 And you got Sarah DeCosta who's crushing it with her girls organization over in Rhode Island. Lindsay Fry is not only working with the girls youth organization there, but they actually the Arizona coyotes and some other investors built an ice rink, just two surfaces, just for girls and women's hockey only no boys hockey in that rank. So the girls are doing everything that they can. I just going back. I just want to touch on something that you said that really intrigued me our problems right now, I think, just going a little deeper, thinking a little further down the road to what our problems are how we're going to get investors and sponsors.
31:52 We are growing the girls and women's hockey organizations. The girls are loving it. They don't feel any different. It's usually when they get to a certain point around the puberty level where they start to think, okay, I've been playing for a few years, I'm getting really good, but they're. Also, parents are dumping a lot of money into their special training clinics, elite programs and, truth be told, girls to develop If they really are talented. Parents are coming to me and have been saying look, the girls organizations. They're just not designed to further develop the top talented girls because they're trying to keep something for the lower level talented girls, to keep them into the programs.
32:37 If they challenge them too fast, those other girls drop. It's too much physically for them. They're not used to, they're not acclimated. So a lot of talented girls rely on boys elite programs for a couple things One, for the extra time, the developing that the boys have, the higher level practices, higher level of tournaments. But to be recruited for college here's the problem. Not too many recruiters are going to go to boys programs just to watch one girl on that team. We had the opportunity to coach a lot of checking clinics where we taught mechanics to boys and girls who are just transitioning into Peewe and, like you said, the body.
33:20 Right around that level, the youth level, girls are actually maturing physically a lot faster than the boys. The problem is let's take an example, jim fitness test that the kids go through in schools. Boys and the girls have different standards. Of course the girls had fewer standards fewer sit ups, fewer push ups. Girls girls didn't even have to do pull ups, they just have to dangle from the bar. Even though pediatricians support the fact that girls mature faster than boys physically, they actually, when we go through these checking clinics, the girls physically react the same, if not a little faster. They can handle the physical checking.
34:01 If they learn the mechanics properly. They can take a check just like a boy and boys, even though through puberty they might appear to be changing physically. It's really when they start lifting weights and when boys start lifting weights. Now girls are starting to do it with their sports because even in college college women's ice hockey programs they have to go to the weight rooms Five days a week just like the boys. So they have to prepare physically If they're going to play at the women's collegiate physically lifting weights. So now we're looking at kids between 12 and 16. Honestly, I think it's safe. Any woman that's played on the women's Olympic national team has been there at that level.
34:44 They'll say they can certainly handle it. And I think I want to point out a gentleman named John Brinkus. He was an extraordinary Ted talker speaker. He spoke on the topic of why girls and boys should play sports. He analyzes the limitations of human performance. He had a front row seat in analyzing the world's greatest athletes of both men and women, and in it he tells us the idea that we have women, that we have woven into our fabric, into our especially American DNA, that bigger, stronger, faster means that you're better, is actually wrong. The same data that bigger, faster, stronger means you're better it's been projected on a wide swath of population and it's held them down unnecessarily.
35:29 And we project that on our girls and we tell them from day one You'll never be as fast, you'll never be as big, you'll never be as strong, so don't even try. Yeah, so they're going to separate you out and there'll be boys leagues and girls leagues and we're not going to play together. So this is actually very damaging to a little girl's ego, to what is possible for her. We're telling her you're never going to compete professionally with the boys, so don't even develop with the boys and that's modeled for girls all the way up to professional level. That's really why these former professional men and women are coming into my organization to change this illusion, or what we've programmed. So girls, little girls when they see men and women coming in together, coach and mentor and actually encouraging girls to play in maybe boys leagues in their primary season and then in a girls spring summer league, but to get that exposure from recruiters.
36:26 That's more what we're looking to promote. Now we understand that some girls don't have that goal, so we want them to have the all girls leagues to be able to play in. So we're not really encouraging all girls, but what we're trying to say here, if we want to get them to the professional level or even have that possible chance from the very beginning, we need to reprogram them and to let them feel comfortable and they're not different from boys. When they're practicing with them, they're actually going to benefit them. The boys are going to benefit because when I found talented girls are practicing with a boys elite team, what I see is the boys actually look at the girl.
37:07 As you know, she's encouraging them to work hard because they see her work in twice as hard. That's what I was told. The best advice I was ever given to my father was you don't have to be the best, but you will have to work twice as hard as everybody. Ok, it doesn't matter whether you play with girls or boys, you're always going to have to play twice as hard, but you don't have to be the best. With that being said, as I was playing with boys, I knew I had to work twice as harder. So everything they did, I did twice as harder and, with them seeing it, they were like she can't work harder than me. I'm a boy, I'm supposed to be stronger and do more than her. So they worked harder to just to keep up with me. Not to go faster than me, but to keep up with me.
37:49 I pulled them up in my youth, yeah it's a healthy competition. Is everything this competition? Yeah. So a lot of girls. They like that competition, they have a passion for sports and they're true athletes from the very beginning. And even reffing as I've been reffing a lot of talented elite boys games or men's games I found more and more girls are coming to watch because they've never seen a woman ref boys or men's. And even the coaches at first were like I've never seen a woman coach. And I said that's really sad, because we've got a lot of talented players. Why aren't they transitioning into officiating college professional Olympic? All that because no one's recruiting and no one told them there's more than just being a player.
38:34 You can be a coach to it, all these levels. But then when I was collegiate coaching I took a look around and I saw maybe 13% were women. At the college level they were mostly men. As I talked to a lot of girls that were coming up through the ranks that I was coaching through the youth, then through the college programs, and then they said now what do I do? I want to play professional. And I said what about coaching? What about reffing in the meanwhile? And they sort of shook their head like I never thought of that. I never thought of that. And I said definitely. So I guess I think that's my whole point. Right, if that's the end goal. Right, because the conversation I have my father, michelle, is the same as your conversation. I was a buck 15 in high school. You want to play. You better, keep up, you can get your.
39:14 You're getting your butt kicked boy, girl, I don't know what, it doesn't matter to me. Bottom lines you want to compete. If you're a competitor or a competitor, it might not be the most popular statement in the world, but there are just differences are going to. If I have a kid that's graduating college and he gets to play professional hockey in an equal league, then let everybody go out there and compete, but I think what you're saying, though, is exactly my point earlier. If we want more officials girls, if we want more girls coaching, if we want, then we have to have more girls leagues earlier, and then put that little 10 year old girl reffing the six year old girls. Listen, this is just my experience, and I've done a lot of programs and a lot of very large programs, like hundreds and hundreds of kids in a youth program, and I found, in the majority of the programs I've worked in, if I separate the girls earlier and put them in girls groups alone together, I get more girls at the end.
40:08 Now, do I get the girls that are surpassing or better, that are just physically better? Are they advancing? Yes, I think they're advancing anyway. But if you want to grow the numbers right, if you want just the equal amount of girls as boys, the fact is, when I've seen it, when I put girls with girls at eight, nine, 10 years old, they react better with girls than if I inject them into a group of a bunch of 10 year old boys. 10 year old boys they're paying the ass and they have egos and they have. They have their own confidence issues and, whether it's right or wrong, that's just where we are right now. So if I can put girls and I see it all the time we come up with a clinic and I put a bunch of pink helmets together and but I and I talk to them, know, like hockey players- yeah.
40:55 I've never. I'm like, okay, girlies, let's go. It doesn't happen. Like I watched, like Shannon Doyle coach with her kids, like you wouldn't know she's talking to boys, girls, or Mitch shipment, like she's just Adam, like this, this way you're going to do this time we're going to develop you and talk to. I do a lot of work with stuff. I'm a toe and his daughter played for college hockey, professional hockey and his son's playing professional hockey and he would say, oh, and then we're growing up. I just I gave him the same opportunity, but there was only one girl in her town. Or there's only three girls in your town. If you want to grow more girls than you have to find a way to get the girls and the parents because isn't a lot of this, michelle, a lot of the parents saying, oh, my daughter can't do that.
41:37 That's just crazy, that's just really too physical there. Isn't that a lot of? Isn't that a lot of the issue? Anything, parents that, yes, the sport is physically taxing for your daughter. So here's the thing some parents, yes, but most of them when they see it, it's an enlightening experience when you talk to them. When I was an ice hockey director right now hadn't seen me on the ice just yet. I'm greeting parents and I see the boys finding up and the girls are there and I say to the parents why the girls signing up? And they're like what there's no girls hockey here and I just said buckle up you're in for a treat. So I'd start the skills clinic and I do my thing and they're just like, and the girls are like right on the glass and they're like, oh my gosh.
42:22 And so at the very end, just like when I ref games, at the very end, usually the girls waiting there watching their brothers, and I would always give the game puck to a girl I'd find one stuck to the glass. I give it to her and I say, hey, you want to play hockey? I would love to how the parents would come up and I would. They'd say how and I'd say, look, I said there's a lot more than you see. They're just not marketing it well and they're. I'm going to be honest with you. I'm in these ranks trying to start these programs and the directors, a lot of them. They don't have the availability, the surfaces. They give to the boys, the men's, the college kids.
43:04 They're giving girls 10 pm slots. They're giving girls for against us. My point, michelle, is that if we're going to invest money right, if we're investors and we want to invest money, don't worry about the 18 year olds, they're done. Invest in the five year olds, invest it now. Not that they're done, but what I'm saying is I realize you have to have a bridge, I get all that, but there is no bridge if there's nothing on the other side, if there's no highland, like securing that number and that's my point is like I don't see that I walk into a rank. I don't see, oh my god, this ring doesn't. Again, maybe it's just because I'm a sheltered individual in my own home. I don't know if there's a lot of girls that are in the same zone of hockey here, but I see a girls program, a boys program, mixed programs. If I see a power skating clinic and then say girls only power skating clinic, it says a hockey power skating clinic, shooting clinic, are there certain?
43:49 But to you, to exactly what I'm saying, though, is what you're doing. Yeah, you are a pied piper. I have lacrosse in my town. We are very limited numbers of lacrosse players. You know you're going to be a lacrosse player for a whole year because you go out and you see a kid shooting a basketball go, you know you'd be good at lacrosse. Why do you have a freesticker? Why don't you just come up to the field? It's the same thing in girls hockey and I think to your to. What you're saying is, if you want to grow the sport, then you've got to be the patriarch, you've got to be the pied piper, you have to go out physically, hand a stick to a little girl, say meet me here next Sunday. You're coming to a program I think the NHL is doing. I see the girls influence that the NHL has right now and money they're putting into be a girl foundation or whatever all the stuff that they're running to me it's the same impact they're having with girls as boys.
44:36 It's just, I think, the ranks and the ownership and the director level people. They need to not only believe it but see that the financial piece of it is the exact same, if not more, than the boys. The only thing you have to do it is you have to take, you have to, you need an influx in investing, in taking the risk to say, ok, the first four months we're going to have four girls here, but if you let me do this, in eight months we'll have 27 long game. Two years we'll have 84 girls here. But a lot of people don't have that patience. A lot of people don't have the ability to wait. I'll be honest, some regions they do it really well, much like you said, they're running it well. Unfortunately, there are still some regions that are living in the past.
45:20 For example, you know the thing with the ranks. I tell them all the time I said look at the revenue you're generating with your boys organizations, from Mike to Banna. Do you want to double it? Because we can bring in girls are going to generate the same amount of money. They're going to pay the same amount. We pay the same amount of money to become USA hockey members. We pay the same amount for ice slots. So no, we do push the money and they are there. The markets there. There's a lot of girls organizations and even a lot of ranks. There's a lot of girls asking to start them up. Ok, now here's what I've seen where a problem is. You asked me about having an influence on the girls, much like the Flyers organization.
46:08 Let's just say that I've been I coach and ref a lot in the Flyers practice zone that in Voorhees, new Jersey, and in Pensacke, new Jersey and what I found was a lot of the boys organizations they weren't comfortable starting up, or girls organizations. They wanted to put more and more into the boys organizations so that more sponsorships for the boys, because it is expensive for elite boys organizations to play year round. So they wanted all that sponsorship for the boys organizations. Once we asked for a girls organization it was tapping into that and they didn't like that.
46:51 So therefore they sort of put us in awkward slots. So a lot of it's just politics and power from roughing. Kerry Frazier, his own stepson, was a coach. His own grandchildren were on these teams, in these ranks in the Flyers youth organizations. Keith Primo's sons went through the organizations. Danny Brears kids went through the organizations. Chris Terri and sons went through the organizations and interestingly, kerry Frazier, keith Primo and Chris Terri and all had daughters and I had asked them. When I first met them I said why aren't your daughters all playing? And they all looked at me and they're like there's no girls hockey. And I'm just like. I was a little baffled and I just said I'm sorry, what I'm like, you're not going to start it for them.
47:35 And because they were coaching their sons and they said I never even actually thought about it. Now Keith had a sister that played in the professionals up in Canada and he recognized that there was sort of a lack in interest in investing in girls and women's hockey, but he didn't really have the time and resources and the knowledge of the business in USA hockey, which is completely different from the business in hockey in Canada. It's completely different. With that being said, it wasn't until I came in and helped them coach their clinics or ref their children that, all of a sudden, kerry Frazier's daughter started playing, but she didn't play in a girls league, she played in the boys league and they were starting to see that it actually benefited them.
48:20 There was no difference whether they started out in a girls league or a boys league and actually getting them in there, they were getting the same benefits. They were developing. They actually saw it firsthand and said so what can we do to support what you're doing? Because we see the need for it. We know we want to throw the grassroots. We've been doing that with zero money, access resources and by ourselves and the girls. So that's why the former professional men not only want to come in and give their time because they see we're not going to get the money donated. They want to give the girls the real resources and access themselves until we can attract or obtain whether donations, sponsorships, investments.
49:04 But that's going to be needed at every level. I'll say this to Michelle Just again Mike is right in saying like the Pied Piper kind of thing. And when you look at the history here of everything we talked about today, we've gone from a society to girls can't do that to okay. Maybe girls can do that to okay. We're growing the game for girls, but it's still not perfect. And look where I sit as a father today and I know my wife is in the same arena with me is like my daughter is going to have every damn opportunity my son has Now. If she chooses not to pursue hockey, that's fine. Same thing for my son, but she's going to know she can play as much as he does if she wants to do that. And so you're seeing the progression here.
49:45 But it's taken decades and, like most progress, it takes time. But we need people like you, we need former female players and male players to stand up, like you're saying, and say look, there's a place for this. Mike makes a really good point. Mike has always been able to see the macro side of business, which I'm. It's unfortunate to say this Most business owners cannot see anything macro. They only see the cashflow of today and tomorrow and that's it. You said it before, you could double your revenue If you're willing to invest the time into this and you know what. The organizations that have done it and done it successfully junior flyers come to mind are making money. And to all the business owners out there, you have to make money. It's not just out the kindness of your heart, you got to make money, yeah but I can see.
50:29 But I could see, lee, I get it and I could see where you, when there's when it okay. So there's 40 years of boys hockey from six to 9pm, and I get it. If you're a rank and you need to infiltrate that, then it's now. You guys say, okay, I have 1030, but it's just. It's the same conversation we have with the sled hockey, it's the same conversation we have with any other, any kind of other sport, that the access isn't there. So I think the point that Michelle's making and you're saying is if you're a father or a mother of a daughter and you were a high performing athlete and you want to give your time and you can now go to see it happen every day I see iron bound doing it, I see Shannon doing it, I see that locally, like polar bears in mid Fairfields of the world, like these high performing dads and moms are saying, no, this is how it's going to be.
51:16 The boys are going to be on at six, the girls are going to be on at seven. Next week, the girls will be on at six, the boys will be on at seven. It just takes being creative and thinking about the fact that everything can't be in a little box every day Because, like Tuesday nights for the last 50 years, we've always had the 10 new boys here. Guess what? There's a new sheriff in town here and we have a new group of customers that we have to fit in. And not only do you need to fit in, we're going to show you, because we are specializing in this group, that they're going to bring in more revenue, more time in your snack bar, more time in your pro shop, and I think that's where manufacturers have to do a better job, that's where businesses have to do a better job, but honestly, it's the leaders in that space.
51:59 Why do you think Pickleball has taken off in the last three years? Because somebody said I love Pickleball and I'm going to promote the crap out of it and I'm going to make it seem like it's cool. And it ain't cool. Come on, it's Pickleball, but everyone wants to play it because it's easy, it's now accessible. It's the equipment manufacturers have bought in and said we're going to promote Pickleball. They are like. I watched a Pickleball, like national championship, with John McElroy the other day and I was like I was sitting on watching the TV for two hours watching the Johnny McPlay Pickleball. So my point is but that's my point is that's where we as leaders in the hockey community can change it. But the hockey community has to be willing to say, hey, okay, I'll flip with you If you give me this, you give me that, I'll give you this.
52:44 And I think that's whether it's girls, boys, sled hockey, disabled hockey, american Special Hockey Association, whatever it is the pie has to be broken up and it needs to be shareable and then let and then listen. After two years the girls still have six girls on the ice. Then we got to drop it. Sorry, you just didn't do your job, you didn't market it correctly, you didn't grow the support. They're not marketing it. They're not marketing it Because when you market it you're not going to get six girls, you're going to get 60. Usa hockey donated a chip to the Flyer Skate Zone in Voorhees, new Jersey. I remember one year, a nice chip of money that they had, they donated just for them to start up a girls pro hockey program.
53:29 And so they started up a clinic where they gave the girls free ice for, maybe spread out over six weeks, they had over 60 women, Absolutely. But did they keep those 60 women after those clinics finished? No, because they didn't market it. They just said we gave it to you for free and let it go. But when you walk through the rink you see all the junior boys Flyers, but they're getting a lot of money into the boys program. So it's just the girls are getting that unfair advantage there. And again I'm going to place blame on rinks because honestly, as an ice hockey director, when I was the ice hockey director for the Flyer Skate Zone, which is frankly a great rink, they just they really weren't marketing to the girls.
54:16 They brought me in and said, michelle, do something. And I said I can only yell so loud. You need marketing tools, you need to get your coaches out to help the women, and they really weren't. They just didn't do the steps that they needed to do. But some organizations do. I know that they're. They've been working hard and building girls and women's hockey the Flyer Skate Zones and the Flyers organizations is supporting the growth. They recognize it. Three of my former college players actually went on to work for the Flyers and the NHL. So women are working in the NHL. They're benefiting from it. They do see it. It's just there's so many people, I think, that are dropping the ball that we really need the help from, like, the rink directors.
55:02 They're the ambassadors of the rink and, like Mike said, they need to really rethink the landscaping of the revenue because they're not going to bring how to try to figure out how to get more revenue from the boys organizations. And, like Mike said, we're right here. Our money's just as good and it's not just six girls. Trust me when I say you start the first year it's just because they didn't know, but by the time the second year comes around, you're going to have three teams and by the next year rolls around. And that's been everywhere I've been. But, like I said, a lot of people when they see a girl for the first time in the ice. It's now 2023. We've got gold medal, women's hockey.
55:43 We've got women, women breaking men records. It just boggles my mind why they're just not recognizing us as a market which we built. It's 100% and equipment. There's also more revenue, not just us paying for ice slots. As I've tried to point out, there's manufacturing of equipment. We don't need specified custom made equipment. I talked to Bernardo and a lot of the former Olympic women's where they tried to work with NHL to customize women's equipment. They thought they generate new revenue and they found out they didn't work and I said let's take a step back and think about that one. I said they've already invested billions of dollars into customizing it for a hockey player, for his movement, his mechanics.
56:28 Why would you want to change and customize any of it? Our bodies are not that different and honestly, a lot of people say oh, women are smaller, not as built like men. Let me tell you something there's been a lot of successful tiny men that have played in the NHL. That maneuver just fine. Nathan Gurme, there's a lot to give you Derek Plante. I remember playing in a women's league and his wife, Christy, was playing with us and Derek was maybe two inches taller than me, same frame, and people were like, oh, you're going to get hurt. And I'm like, he's not any bigger. And, truth be told, I've played with men. I can absorb it conditioned.
57:08 I've lifted weights Physically. You can prepare your body to withstand those checks. I'll say this, michelle. I'll say this for you All right. Number one is that there seems to be a stigma around the strength between a man and a woman. I'd say not. The 10 strongest people I know are women. I'm going to say that right now. Number two is I'll say this that in strength covers more than just muscle. Let me put it that way. Number two is that women belong in sport. I'm a I vocally say that as often as I can. I work with many women in sport. Some of the most top quality people I've worked with in sport have been women. So I'm saying this because we have to break the stigmas that certain types of people belong in certain fields.
57:49 There might be more men in sport, but that doesn't mean that women don't belong in sport. Michelle, we're running out of time, but I wanted to ask you this last question. I wanted to give you the time to close the show. When you were young, you were told you can't play and something kept you going. You said you met Pat Summit later on and she inspired you to keep going. And I think about when I was growing up in the late 90s is girls were playing on our teams and there was a lot of oh, they don't belong here, but something kept those girls I played with going. As you said, it's 2023. There's a young girl listening to the show somewhere, right. It's hearing everything that we're talking about, in the spirit of everything I just said. What is your message to her? What is the future you want her to see and believe in?
58:31 Because you look, you've pioneered this way Again. People can't see how far we go until they see someone do it the first time. So what is your message to the young girl listening to this show right now that wants to play hockey beyond where she's at right now? Oh, I would tell her to think about where she wants to be in three year increments. How does she want to develop, how does she want to grow? And what I would say is find an environment that will nurture you, that has the support system mentoring, not just coaching, mentoring. Look for those mentors, not just coaches, referees, anybody and not just women, but men.
59:16 You want to look for the right people to surround yourself with At any time. If anyone gives you any discouraging words or wants to steer you in another direction or tell you it's not for you, I would say don't listen to all that. By all means, come into the sport, enjoy it just like the boys, and don't let anyone tell you can't do anything. Your limitations are in your own little head. Just listen to what we're saying, take it and go home, think about it and figure out what works for you and navigate your own journey, your own pioneer, and at the end you'll find you've gained a lot more than you expected or set out to do.
1:00:02 That's fantastic. I mean it like you really are a pioneer in the game, and I'm going to have my daughter listen to this, and I hope all of the parents out there with daughters and sons will listen to this episode, because it's a powerful message about you don't have to stop just because someone tells you to stop. You don't have to think you have a limitation because no one's done it before. You have to step up and you have to take control of your own journey and remember it's only impossible to someone does it, and we say this on the show all the time. We do not know our ability as humans. Every four years, an Olympic record gets broken, every four years. All right, that's the message I think today. Right, michelle, we're out of time, we got to jump off, but it's been great having you on today and I want to thank you so much.
1:00:44 If you want to know more about her or what she does, obviously women's hockey unitedorg is the website correct. People can go there to get more information and I'll give you the final word. Just want to thank you so much for being here today. Oh, thank you so much for having me. This was an exciting dialogue. I really appreciate this opportunity. It means a lot to be able to share this information with girls out there, and you know what I would say to them is get out there, start your own journey, because you're going to crush it. I agree with you. Obviously, we support that message here as well. If Christy was here, she'd be raw round with you, so that's awesome. So that's going to do it for this edition of our kids play hockey, and we can hear all of the episodes on our kidsplayhockeycom.
1:01:24 Once again, if you want to learn more about Michelle's doing women's hockey, unitedorg and feel free if you're inclined. If you like this episode, give us that five star review, share it and get over to our Facebook page. Our kids play hockey couple. Yes or no questions to join. We get more people every day. So for Mike Benelli, michelle Billingsley, I'm Lee Elias. We'll see you in the next episode of our kids play hockey. Take care, everybody. We hope you enjoyed this edition of our kids play hockey. Make sure to like and subscribe right now if you found value. Wherever you're listening, whether it's a podcast network, a social media network or our website, ourkidsplayhockeycom. Also, make sure to check out our children's book when Hockey Stops at when hockey stopscom. It's a book that helps children deal with adversity in the game and in life.
1:02:07 We're very proud of it. But thanks so much for listening to this edition of our kids play hockey and we'll see you on the next episode.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeartRadio
Amazon Music
RSS Feed