When Should Parents Retreat from Coaching Youth Hockey?
Ever wondered when it's the right time for a parent to step back from coaching their child's sports team? Mike and Lee dig into this pressing question, examining how family dynamics, team requirements, and the individual experiences of the child factor in. We specifically dissect the controversies around the 12U mark, pondering the pros and cons of continued parental involvement in coaching.
We also venture into the realm of autonomy in youth sports. The spotlight here is on the evolving game of hockey, the growing necessity for qualified coaches at all levels, and the intense pressure of travel schedules for younger teams. We underscore the importance of fostering independence in children and allowing them to take charge of their sporting journey. In the latter part of our discussion, we delve into the not-so-pleasant aspects of parent coaching, such as nepotism and favoritism, and how they can impact a child's development.
Text The Our Kids Play Hockey Team!
We're powered by NHL Sense Arena!
NHL Sense Arena, is a virtual reality training game designed specifically to improve hockey sense and IQ for both players and goalies. Experience the next generation of off-ice training in VR with over 100+ drills and training plans curated from top coaches and players.
Use Code "HockeyNeverStops" at Hockey.SenseArena.com to score $50 off an annual plan!
Have A Topic You Want Us To Cover? Let us know!
Please Be Sure To Subscribe & Leave A Review For Us On Apple Podcasts, doing so helps our show grow!
Follow Us On Social Media:
0:07 Great topic today brought to you by our Facebook group, our Kids Play Hockey. This was an anonymous reader. Put it on. There is when should a parent stop coaching? What age should a parent stop coaching? So, mike and I dive into this today fully Also start of the hockey season and we really appreciate all of your love. We have just had the greatest month we've had in the history of this podcast Most listens in one day, most listens in one week, most listens in one month and that is because of you. So, no sponsor today, just a big thank you from all of us here at our Kids Play Hockey for helping us grow this podcast and a humble request to share the podcast with your new teams, with your new parents, anybody you think that would benefit from the conversations that we have.
0:48 We want you to share it because, at the end of the day, the three of us were just talking hockey, but we're really trying to create a better community for those hockey parents that just want to make it a better place for their kids and a better place for the game. So if you're inclined to do that, please share our Kids Play Hockey. We're going to have a QR code you can share. We're going to have a lot of different ways to do it, but, of course, word of mouth is the best. So please share our Kids Play Hockey if you have the time. We appreciate you, thank you, thank you. Thank you so much for helping us find success with this show, and here we go. Let's dive into the episode with Mike and I about what age should a parent stop coaching. Hello hockey friends and families around the world, and welcome to another edition of Our Kids Play Hockey. I'm Leo Lies, joined by Mike Benelli, and today we are going to be answering a question that was posted anonymously on our Facebook group, our Kids Play Hockey.
1:35 Make sure you join it. If you haven't, you have to answer a couple yes or no questions. It's a great group with a lot of great questions, a lot of great conversation. Not competition, maybe this competitive conversation, who knows? But Mike, someone wrote on an anonymous post asking the question to share their thoughts on when parents coaching their kids should stop. So today's episode is going to be how long should a parent coach their kids? And, as many of you listening probably know, some of you might have strong opinions on this. Some of you might be going. It depends. We have the great master level coach, mike Benelli, on the air today. Mike, let's start with our thoughts on this, and then I'm going to dive into some of the comments that we got on this post because, as I said, it's a little bit around the board, right? I think a lot of it depends on location, a lot of it depends on organization, a lot of it depends on experience, right, mike?
2:20 Why don't you share your thoughts on this before we dive in? Yeah, so full disclosure, I'm currently coaching my 16-year-old and assistant coach. I'm on the bench, though, and I am making an impact, I guess, on the who plays and who doesn't play and the lineup and all that kind of stuff, so there's so many variables to this that I think people get caught up in. Well, you're a parent, or you're his dad, or you're his mom, or you're his uncle, or you're on the board, and that's why you're doing it. So there's a lot of different variables, but I think, overall, my feeling has always been this, since the day I started coaching, when I didn't have kids the best quality person with the most knowledge that can guide and mentor the players on my team, the best is who I want there Now and then, if I'm a youth organization, can I do that economically?
3:17 Can that dad provide a lot of the things that I want and I get my case? Listen, I coach. Well, I love coaching. I got to go to the rink anyway. My son's on the team. He's been great at allowing me to coach him. That's almost getting that permission to be like. Listen, I'm going to be on the bench again this year. It's not going to be okay because it's a lot of money. I'm going to be going all over the country and I'm not a good guy sitting in the stands, so I mean, for me it's really maybe it's more about me than about him, but again, I think I bring a lot of. I think and this is the majority of cases of parent coaching that the parent brings so much to the table that it's only benefiting the other 15, 20 kids on the team at the expense of their kids.
4:12 That's my experience in seeing this more than anything. But again, I've never seen it as a hard and fast rule. No, parents, they can't coach, they shouldn't be on the bench. I think it's really a piece by piece, team by team decision. And then how long should they do it? Listen, this is youth hockey. I mean there's some coaches that have coached their kids in pro right. So I think it's. I actually just talked to a very prominent Division One coach and his son is going to be going looking at Division One offers and he's like I don't want my kid coming to play for me, but he wants to come play for me and this is at the college, the Division One level. So it's really I think you got to look at it family by family in your circumstances.
4:57 But overall I would just say find the best qualified person and keep them on the bench as long as you can. Yeah, look and again, as we dive into this, like most things on the show, there's different ways of looking at it. I just wrote some notes here. Right, there's personal reasons to or not to coach, then there's professional reasons to or not to coach, and they're very, very different realms. And then, looking through the comments again, like most things, there's this kind of split around 12 U right Of should it happen or not. I think I think everyone kind of unanimously agrees. Like you know, squirt might Adams is expected just because you need a lot of volunteers. At that age you don't need to have an extremely in depth knowledge of the game, and I think USA Hockey does a really great job of helping new dads, new moms, just kind of say OK, look, you got to get them skating, you got to learn these basic skill sets.
5:47 Here's what a small area game is. So I think for the purpose of the episode, we'll just agree now that from from a 12 U down right, I mean, you know again, squirt might Adams, it's somewhat expected and we need those parents to keep the game going. It's just almost impossible, at least in the United States, mike, to keep the game going without that. We should also note, though we've said this many times on the show you go over to Scandinavia, you go overseas. The best coaches are paid to teach that age group because you want your best coaches teaching the new players and that's how you have kind of a hockey developer system. Mike, you want to comment on that? Yeah, no, it's just the most important time for those kids to develop and their model is they have certified, trained teachers and instructors, and I think that the trainers they call them.
6:35 So I think that's important and, again, if you're in a youth hockey organization, you can do that and not break the bank and understand that development is first. Well, and I'll tell you, sometimes it might be apparent you have so many good hockey people in your building, but again, a lot of it, just a lot of it is just you have good people, like they do in Europe, and they're trained and they take your kids Great. But we have to be really careful that the system doesn't implode on itself by the fact that you're paying somebody you know $20,000 to be a head coach of a 10-U team. We should also note that different countries have different geopolitical systems that probably give a lot of funding to youth sports.
7:20 You give and take with that. There's great parts about it, there's drawbacks to that, but at the end of the day, when we look at the youth, the younger youth levels, you always hope that the dad or the mom or the coach is yearning for knowledge. One of the things I've really loved over the last three years now is seeing the game from a different point of view. I never got to play hockey at that age. I didn't start till I was 12. So to be able to experience the game through my six almost seven-year-old and my nine almost 10-year-old for the last few years has been really fun. And again I'm going to say this again USA Hockey, I think, does a great job of providing the information you would need to be a successful coach. Now, when you get to that Pee, wee and Up level, I've got one comment here. I won't say the name because I know this person, but I know her kids play in a AAA organization 12 U and Up and they said that there's a cutoff there, that 12 U and Up they actually won't allow parents to coach.
8:11 Now what I'm curious about is this there's a difference between volunteering to be a coach in Adams and then you're getting your coaching certifications and you become a pretty good coach and then you get above 12 U I'm like this is where I'm with you is that I want the right person for the job, I want the best person for the job. You're hoping at that age group that a parent can kind of and again, this is where that professional and personal thing comes in kind of separate themselves from that. Like I've had conversations with my own kids that, look, I'm your dad, but I'm also the coach and I have responsibilities as the coach that apply to every child on the team. It has nothing to do with my love for you, it has nothing to do with how I feel about you, but as the coach, I everyone gets treated the same way in terms of the hockey right.
8:55 So I don't know if if I necessarily agree with there being a hard cutoff of no parent coaches above this age, although I imagine it makes it a lot easier for the organization when it comes down to to to spats or anything like that. And it's in my particular situation, you know it, just um, it's really just, it's actually a gift that the organization is giving to me, like they're allowing me to do this and and, and they know like, well Listen, this guy's gonna be in the building. How are we not using him? And I get the coach now and I'm not I'm not the head coach, so I get to be with a coach that I really like and respect and and I want to learn from and I and I love that I can kind of hand my son off to him right, even at any age. I mean, you're always, listen, I'd rather.
9:36 I'd rather be on the guy, I'd rather be on the bench. You know row, in the same way than throwing anchors out, you know up in the stands, and I'm not that person anyway, like I just never would be that that person rip it on the coach or rip it on other players. But I, in my, in my circumstance, I Almost, like I really go out of my way to treat the other boys on the team Like I want my son treated right. So so they're getting the benefit of, I think, in my you know, and maybe I get probably have to ask those parents, but of me saying listen, I'm not gonna sit here and just berate you and yell at you and and and when I was a coach, as when I was a coach of and I didn't have kids and we I think we've talked about this a couple of times on the show is like I was a Completely different person.
10:21 I was a, I was a completely different coach. Right, I never, I never appreciated and this is before you know, we didn't have all this other educational pieces and discussions and nobody really talked about what happens when the kids leave the ring Right, and and I never really appreciate the fact that you know those kids are gonna go home to mom and dad and they're hurt and they're disappointed and they're frustrated and they're you know, they, they want answers and I'm like, listen, just, I'm the coach, listen to me, that's all there is to it and, you know, shut your mouth and show for practice. So the game's evolved and I think you know, if you can find a good person, that's evolved with it. I don't care what level, it is right, you know that that person be on the bench.
11:01 But again, I I've purposely, you know, kind of set back and I didn't even I didn't even really actually even asked to help Until after the team was picked anyway, like I kind of took myself out of the mix. Right and smart, we're gonna be, and then I don't want to be involved in the selection process. I just want to be in part. I just want to be involved in the teaching process right. And yeah, you know, and that's what I'm good at and I and I think I could bring a lot of value to that and I think, financially it's just like you know, for me it's like, well, jesus, if I'm gonna be going, all I don't. It's crazy. I mean, at the 16, 17, 18 level, the amount of traveling these kids do, it's ridiculous, yeah, it's crazy. It's crazy, and then you'd be a part of you know, away from your family and family I mean.
11:45 So there's so much that goes into it. But you know, to me I don't know if there's a cut-off age. I think there's like an age where you want to leave and you want to cut that, not that off. But if it's if the, if the staffs just not there, then I don't think there is a cut-off age, I think what I would say. There's an age of consideration, right where it's like okay, who do we have in the mix that can coach at this level If we need them to? Like you said, if they're not there, you have to have someone volunteer to coach, right? You know, if there's a qualified parent versus a 19 year old that just wants to get into coaching, you know I want the parent to teach the 19 year old to so forth and so on, right? By the way, I also want to echo what you said, because I know I've get this question a lot with with my friends and squirt and might about To travel at the AAA 18.
12:30 You, it's insane, it's like an NHL travel schedule. It's just less games. I mean, you're all over the country, it's it's. It's pretty insane. So you know I'm with you, mike, you want to have some control over that, alright. Next next comment here from Sarah says my husband has been coaching our son since 8u. He is also a 14u major now and my husband has decided to pull away and stop coaching so our son can have his quote-unquote time away from family with his buddies and with his space. It's hard because our son seems to enjoy that out there, but really don't know if he's just saying that and we want him to form some independence and autonomy. And then she says you know to figure out what's right. There's no right answer and you know it's interesting because I feel like I'm at that place a little bit now.
13:11 So again, just to reorientate everybody, I've got two kids playing, one's first-year might, now once first-year squirt. So now I have to make a choice. Right now I'm in this position where, okay, I can't, can't be involved with both teams. So luckily, my son's 10u team, the coaching staff, was set. It was and I had full respect for that. I'm not gonna push my way into a situation where I'm not being asked to right. So I love it because my son is now in a position when he has to have that autonomy and I also think it was a position where I needed to pull back a little bit and let him have his space. I was feeling that that's the, that's the personal reason right now. With that said, my daughter who's the might Is like will you come coach me?
13:52 Will you help out? And you know I told of course I'll help out, because I did that for my son I also might you know this right, you don't want ever one kid to think, well, why do you only coach with that team and not my team, right? So I kind of had it set before the season that I was going to help out my daughter's team because because I did that for my son and I would like to do that for my daughter also. My son, who's older, like he can handle it now, like, like that, that was part of the job. Right for me was, hey, you can go do it yourself now. So I think that that's. It's an interesting comment, because, again, when you look at the personal reason, you know it, I don't care how qualified I am. If my kid wants some space, I gotta respect that right.
14:36 Because I think, mike, later on if you don't respect that both ways, obviously it can be really detrimental to your relationship with your own kid and I don't want that to happen. Yeah, listen, I sat around these, you know these, these, these, all these AAA, you know showcases and tournaments and rinks and and, and you know the dads in the stands are all you know, pro coaches, college coaches, right, and that coach and their kid, like they're just, they're just like, listen, you're the coach, and those are the best parents. Parents of the coaches are the best parents, I think I mean most of the time they're like you know. So I do, listen, I get, I get a lot of benefits out of coaching because you know, but I and I, and I really do, I think I like, I don't think, I know that the parents most wouldn't even know my son was on the team, unless I, you know.
15:23 The only reason they know is because we have the same last name. But they don't know, you know, I don't, you know, I don't. It's just, you know, at the detriment of him probably is like, listen, I'm as easy and hard on all of them the same, but at the same time, you know you, you mentioned it about your little guys. So you know, it's funny, we had a. So the kids that I coach now are all getting their licenses right. They're all getting like permits and licensing, and so they're really at the point right now we're over the course of the year to now and the end of the year a lot of them will get their license and drive on their own. And the greatest comment I heard, I think, all weekend, was the one mom telling her son like hey, it isn't going to be great, you're going to get to drive yourself to the rink and go to practice on your own.
16:04 And he's like I'm going to miss, I'm going to miss driving to the rink with dad. You know like, and then and then, and I'm like, I'm like, did he start crying? Like when did he start crying about that? Like I was like how come I can't get that. Nobody's saying that about me. So I mean, I think it's just, you know it all depends on your relationship. That's a big thing too. Like, when should you step down? Well, a lot of it's the relationship with your kid. If it's affecting your relationship in a negative way, then obviously, you know we always hear the horror stories. You know, maybe I'll get it someday too is like oh, my God, I hate it. Like I, but I'm always like for me, I check in a lot, but when you got to know your, you got to know your family and you got to know your situation.
16:46 And I think, more and more importantly, if you are that coach is going to continue to coach your son or daughter through you know, over 12, you 14, you 16, you, then you better be articulating this to the other families about why you're doing it, how important it is for them to understand that you want to help everyone and how you can be the biggest benefit to their kid, you know, and to their player. So you know, if you're going to be, you know, and honestly, if I was coaching right now, like if I was back in coaching a professional team, a prep school team, a college team, I wouldn't have the time to coach. I just happened to have the time to coach. So that's you know. You know, neither here nor there, I don't know how to even.
17:27 You know, just like I'm here, I'm coaching, I like to coach, I'm available, I'm going to, I'd like to do it Now if I was, if I had, you know, because I'm a, that's how I define myself, it's what I do for every day, right? If I was an accountant or a stockbroker and I happen to coach my kid, maybe, maybe that's a different situation for those people because at some point you want to give them, you know, back again to the best qualified person that's going to advance them at the highest level. And if you know, mike Sullivan lost his job tomorrow and his kid was a 16 year old, I would ask my Sullivan to get on the bench with me, right, if, if, if, if this person was on my you know, you see it all the time.
18:08 You know, ron Brindamore's son played for Quinnipiac University this year, right. And if Rod Brindamore lost his job during the season, I think Rand Pectall will call him up and be like hey, why don't you, why don't you come to the staff? I mean, you know, because you just find the best people. Yeah, I think you also make a point. You and I are outliers in this right, like we're. We're very unique examples in the way we approach it, because this is what we do for a living right, but, like you said, the accountant right, that doesn't do it for a living. That's a great. It's a great point you're bringing up here, like I forget to think about that sometimes that, like you know, hockey is what we do. So when it comes to you know, the dad that works construction, I mean, or whatever right it does, driveways does, does garage doors, it's a little bit of a different thing.
18:51 The question is too, is you know, how much do you love coaching, right? I think there's also a point where it's like, well, I'm doing this because they need a coach to. Okay, I need to coach, I want to coach, right? You know it brings up a couple couple of funny things too. You know we have to bring up the word nepotism here a little bit, because I have been on teams. I have worked on teams where there is a parent and a kid and it is clear that that kid is getting favorability from their parent. It's a very hard situation. There's not much you can do, you know, and then commiserating happens. And why is that kid getting more ice time than everybody else Else? Excuse me, you know, typically the kid is very talented at that point. But as a dad I don't want to put my own kid in that position right, where they're having to deal with this.
19:37 Not the kid's fault, right, it's not anybody's fault. That's not the right word. But it's like I actually don't want to be in a position where people are going to be giving my own kid any flack because I'm the coach right Now. Granted, I haven't had that yet and the parents? I've been very blessed so far in my kids' youth hockey journey that all the parents have been fantastic. I've just had no pushback. But it's just something to think about, right? You know I always talk about putting ego aside, go ahead. Right and honestly I've seen it worse, not as a dad coach, but the nepotism of the country club friend, Like honestly I've seen coaches that they're not you know they're not. They're not the dad on the bench, they just happen to be friends with all the other parents.
20:19 That's worse. I think it's because it to me it's like, oh well, of course this kid's playing, like I watch it all the time, like, oh, they're playing because you know they made the team, because they're buddies and they're that's what they. They hang out together. Oh, every weekend on Facebook they're fishing together or they're playing golf or like. And then you wonder why the kids getting you know extra. Or or the worst is like the nonparent coach that has a private lesson skating and stick handling clinic that he makes the kids go to and like I said, hey, you, you're going to play for me, you better show up at these clinics, you better show up these extra things and pay me and I'm going to tell you how good you are. And then it's just a bad cycle. So again, it's all the circumstances you're in If you have a pro coach, take the dad out, find me the best person, right.
21:01 And if you find me the best person that happens to have a kid that can make the team on their own and play and be a competent contributor to the organization, great. In my case again, it's a little different, but like there's no coach that does what I do for a 16 year old team on, that's apparent. So you know, between video and teaching and education, and you know, making sure my podcast gets gets shared, you know on a daily basis. You know all that stuff is just at some point, yes, you have to let the kids go. I get it a hundred percent and I and I and I, me and I think a lot of guys I know, and girls that coach their kids through like kind of the high school level, are probably doing it because that's just what they do for that's what they do, right, and they're not going out of their way to say, oh, I'm going to, I'm going to jump in here because you know I, you know I've nothing better to do.
21:58 Like, I trust me, I'd much rather be able to hand my son off and be with and I've done that. I think I've done that. I think I've handed him off to another human being that I trust and I can support and I feel like another pair, like I really try to be, like in the game ends. I try to be a parent, I try to go. You know I try to yeah, I don't want to be like you know. I even asked the people like, don't call me, coach Benelli, like I'm, you know I'm helping. I want to be on the inside track to help your kids right? And I can do that because I kind of have us. I have an inside, just been inside information, like I can help you. You know I can help you because I know that you're all our kids, because our kids are all the same. They're all struggling at 14, 15, 16 years old.
22:39 So help them all, that's all. I look at it and I think a parent comes. Parent is a whole different perspective. They really are. Then. Then then some guy who's coaching your kids at 16, Doesn't have kids, doesn't understand what happens when they go home, doesn't understand about girls, doesn't understand about the stresses of of academics, doesn't understand the stresses of the home life, because they don't most. I'm gonna say in all a lot, don't care. Show up at the rink, do your job, go home. That's my extent of my relationship with you. I think when you're a dad or a mom on the bench, that relationship I think, from where I've seen it, goes deeper. Yeah. I agree with and if I can, if I can have that, if I can have that relationship, you know, as long as I can, and if I can find people that can do that for me in other organizations, I think that's great.
23:29 I think it's but and and that, and I'm sure we could get, I'm sure we, as we get down to the comments, right, you see him that there are some ugly, ugly incidents. No doubt about it. There are some times when it's just like what the hell? Like I. But you know what. We've talked about this a million times about picking your team. You know that going in, you know that that's gonna be a problem, so you went on that team anyway. So I think it's just you know, if you know it's gonna be a problem ahead of time, then don't. Don't try out for that team. Well, I'll tell you a couple notes on what you just said here. I wrote some down, you know. Number one is that I am definitely a different coach since having kids and coaching my own kids Then prior. I think that's a really important distinction. I really enjoy helping young coaches that don't have kids.
24:12 Maybe see that perspective. I have no problem being an assistant on a team with a young coach that is open to being mentored. I think that that I wish I had had that when I was younger. Right, I can also tell you this. I've said this a long time ago in a previous episode, but it's so tough to put in words. We, you know I care about those kids so much. It's not that I care about my kid more, it's. It's tough to explain to a parent how much a good coach really cares about your kid. It's not just about the hockey and what they do on the, the ice. You know when you get to the, when you get to the professional level now we're seeing changes in that, where it used to be all right, you're a cattle and I'm hurting the cattle and I need to win, even now at the pro level, that you have to have a relationship with these players.
24:55 You have to know them and understand them. Even though you could trade them right Like you got, there's a whole nother layer to this. But one of the things I found crazy was that you know over the last few years like I really, really care about these kids. You know I want them to do well, you want them to succeed. You see them in the ring after you've coached them How's everything going and you know it's sometimes they're shy, which is okay. The next thing you said, mike, that maybe you know I thought about this. You know I've had plenty of time now where I have been in the stands and not on the bench. You know my first few years was always on the bench because of COVID and you know I think by far one of the greatest compliments I get From people is them just asking me questions in the stands of like, hey, what would you do with this situation?
25:37 What would you? Because because there's a clear trust that you know I care right and I really don't take those questions for granted. When a parent comes up to me and says, hey, what would you do in the situation, it means a lot to me. I've also realized and anybody who knows me personally, this will make you laugh. But If, for someone who speaks for a living, I'm incredibly quiet when I'm watching a game, even even when my son's in net, I typically Rarely say anything good or bad, right, I remember he made a huge save the other week and everybody should I just kind of Just quiet and the people like but you know, you don't cheer at all and I was like, wow, I don't know how to explain that one. I mean, you can't really do that too much on the bench either if you're doing it right.
26:19 Right, so so it was, but I'm going to coach coach mode, where just a little more even healed. Yeah, yeah. Well, the other thing, too, is that and this is me personally is that my Gauge on my son's play or my gauge on his performance, that's a better word is not Based on saves or, you know, goals against or anything like that same thing with with when they skate out. It's not about how many goals did you score, how many assists did you make. I know, I note that I see that it's more of how did you conduct yourself as a person? Did you, did you work hard the whole game? I can tell you right now my proudest moments of my own son. I'm very proud when he plays great, don't get me wrong.
27:02 But I'm probably even more proud when he gets, you know, sheldon a game and he never quits right, keeping in mind he's he's under 10, right, it's a little different when it's older, I guess. Well, maybe it's not. My point is this is that when I see he's not giving up and he's taking care of his teammates, or my daughter, who's young, when a kid gets hurt in Adams, or when she's a might now, she goes to make sure they're okay, that's a really proud moment for me. And I've heard parents. I'm like whoa, buddy, all right, there's just yes, and a parent one time tell that this is bold, you know what? Because kids not getting up. It's like whoa. But that's my gauge. It doesn't have to be everybody else's gauge. I want to read another comment here and I don't want to.
27:45 I don't, I do not want to gloss over this one. Christine says I wish more moms were coaching, and I completely agree with her. I've been lucky enough in my organization this year, multiple moms coached in our summer league. I've seen moms coaching on the bench. There's no reason why women should not be invited to coach as much as males, and especially the Adams and the might levels. If we're talking about getting into coaching. Right, I'd love to see more more women coaching the game of hockey. Yeah, I mean it's. That's foreign to me. Like I said a lot about a lot of things, because I just like, if you want to coach and you played wife where, yeah, yeah, you crazy, your coach, if you coach, you coach.
28:26 You know, and I think some of the best you know, I know, some of the best coaches my kids have had have been women and Men and young guys and young and young girls. I got, I run, I do lacrosse clinics every week and our best, our best teachers, which is I don't know, I shouldn't say this to the guys, but the best teachers are the girls that are out there Because they just really have fun. There's no expectation, you know. There's no like, like, it's not even expectations, they're just more, they're kinder. Like they're not yelling. You gotta be careful with Mike man. I've met some women. No, I know, I know they are they're kinder. They're kinder to the kids of being like no, no, you're doing great, like that's a really good thing you're doing.
29:07 And the boys too, the high school boys. Like they're not jaded, they're not like there's no expectations. Like young men and women that are like new to coaching, they're the best coaches sometimes. So if I can get a young lady that's just finished playing, a young man who's just finished playing, that's not like, that's not in it for the wrong reasons. Like listen, we've talked about this too right, about getting a new coaching job. Like the first thing you don't ask is how much does it pay? Because when you hear how much it pays. You're gonna go. Oh God, I don't know if I want to do this and I'm like, yeah, no, you don't want to do this, run away as much as you can. But if you're going to do it, do it for the right reasons and do it where you know, if you can, you know. So her comment about she was, you know, I don't think it has anything to do with age, I think it has the organizational's, you know, mission and their own kind of pool of candidates.
29:57 But certainly, I mean, I don't. I think the game needs more diversity across the board. Agreed, and you know, it's always great to if your kids can get different voices. We're dealing with it right now. We have a couple of dads that coached their kids and now they're kind of handing it off. And I was joking. I said, yeah, like I'm actually looking forward to doing that. You know, after this season I really am Like and I have a 10 year old, so I have my squirt who's at the same question Like, well, aren't you gonna coach my team next year? I'm like, well, I can't, I don't times coach anybody and actually I don't even like coaching anymore. So probably not, I'm probably gonna retire. No, but I and I will. I'll jump in, I'll ask if I can help. I want to be involved. Let me know what I can do and if they'll have me please, and if not, then you know I'm gonna coach in the car.
30:44 You know like against the coach, so better have me on the bench. Mike's trying to retire to become a full-time podcasting host. Right, the dream, no. My comments on this, too is like I'm very proud. My son and daughter have a female coach for their school team this year. I'm happily assisting her in whatever I can do. I think that I should also say this, and I gotta preface this in no way am I wording this like there's permission or anything like that. But I actually know a lot of women who just never even thought, oh, I could volunteer for that. Right, and I want you to know you can. Right. It's like if you're interested in helping out and coaching your kids, you can do it. This goes for anybody, right. It's just, you know, sometimes it's not top of mind, and every female coach I've worked with has been wonderful.
31:31 The other thing, too, is that I have learned. Unlike you, mike, I never really cared who it was man, woman, anything in between, you know, race none of that mattered to me. You gotta be willing to learn from anybody, and I think that I've learned a lot from especially looking at NCAA programs and professional women coaches. They've taught me a lot. I've just had my mind open to it, and you know, it makes me think this too. I wrote this down and this is true for the whole conversation of just parents coaching. When your ego trumps your ability to grow as a coach, you're no longer a coach. All right, and Mike, you said this perfectly earlier when you were talking about I was a very drastically different coach when I was younger.
32:14 Exactly, you should have been, and you should be a very drastically different coach probably 15 years from now. If you're still coaching when your ego trumps your ability to grow as a coach, you are no longer a coach, right, and that's one of the things about coaching. I am obsessed with learning more about coaching. I love learning more about coaching. I wanna know what different people do. I love working with different personalities, people from different backgrounds, with different diverse backgrounds, because I always learn something, and if you look at my resume, you can see I've worked with a lot of crazy different teams that people probably wouldn't think of, and I'm always learning something. So I think that you know whether your kid's on the team or not. You know if you have a drive to learn to be a better coach, you're gonna probably be in the right place, right?
33:01 I don't think too many of us do it for the money. Mike, to your point. I mean, most of us don't even get paid for the youth levels. Yeah, it's like a wash right. I mean, it's like if you get to coach your team and the organization maybe saves some money by getting you and you're a good coach anyway and you can help out in other levels. Listen, it's an interesting question and subject that we have to answer as directors and program administrators and then come up with that philosophy. And I just, I've always been like a guy who's like don't paint yourself into the corner. I mean, I've told the story before. You know, in New York, when I was coach, when I was a hockey director, my first year, you know, we had a no parent policy.
33:44 You know, in the youth hockey space and a lot of it had to do with me. Right, I'm like, well, I wanna pay my buddies here to coach and you know, I'll get all my college guys, all these guys are gonna be coaching with me. I love it and I don't have to answer to any of these parents. And we can, you know, isolate ourselves. And so the organization's like, yeah, no parent, no parent coaching. And all of a sudden, you know, marcel Dion walks in the room with his two kids. He's like, hey, can I help out in the ice? And the director's like, no, there's no parent coaching. I'm looking at him like are you insane? Like are you talking about yeah, you can come on the ice? I said you're not even only an exception, you're like a wanted resource. So I think it all and again and then maybe that goes to you know, the question is are you a head coach, assistant coach, a skills coach, a helper, an advisor, somebody that you want to count on to help with the kids, even though you're a parent?
34:37 Like there's plenty. Look at all these kids around the. You know the youth hockey landscape right now that are high level executives in the NHL. You're not. You don't want that person's opinion Like you don't want that person's input. So I would say I would say grab those people as much as you can and use them. Well, look, I think we're actually coming to an answer here too. Another comment here from Magnus. You wrote a really, really long comment. I can't read the whole thing, but at the end here he says short answer if they're doing good at the job, it doesn't matter if they're a parent or not. If they're doing a bad, they should probably be replaced. So it really comes down to qualifications at the end of the day. Another one here from Dan, who's a, I know, a huge listener of the show.
35:18 He says you know he's a coach. As far as coaching your own kid, I think it's more between the kid and the coach or parent. As long as the club is happy with the coach and they don't have a million accusations of favoritism or something like that, else, like that, it's okay. And then he goes on to say that you know his son plays and that they have a conversation every off season or before every season of hey, are you okay with this? Do you want me to keep doing this? So Dan's doing a great job of. It's not about me, right? And like, I've seen the opposite of this. So like, well, I'm the 18U AAA coach. Well, that is great, don't get me wrong, but I don't think that trumps your relationship with your child, keeping in mind too, it's only a few years that that wouldn't be happening. And Dan goes on to say I run clinics, private lessons, professionally educate coaches.
36:02 So he's in the game, right? Like we got to remind myself this that if you're in the game, you're coaching consistently, at some point your kids are going to come through right, and I just think at that point you have to make some decisions on whether you want to do it or not. There'll always be a place for you. You know if you're doing it right. But again he goes on to say you know, it depends, right. Another comment here this one was interesting and I think it's to your point, mike. Jeff says our league is literally built on the idea of dad's coaching. If not them, then who? I will say. To the best of my knowledge, every coach we have is at least played through high school and all are certified through USA Hockey. So I don't know where Jeff is located, but that might be a location where there's not a ton of coaches to pick from and they rely on the parents to kind of educate themselves and learn.
36:47 I do want to go back to USA Hockey does a pretty good job, especially with qualifications, if you have to go through a certain amount of education to be able to coach, especially at the higher levels. I'm not just going to let any shmo walk in off the court. Well, the coach developer program is literally the gold standard, you know, for coaching education and I think that's a great resource that we all have to take, as parents and as administrators and youth hockey coaches. And again it all comes down to if you don't mind spending an average, what I mean? Would you going to charge an extra $800,000 per kid if to have a non-parent coach Because you got to pay people? I mean their time is it's their time.
37:27 I mean you're not going to get a lot of young or non-parent coaches out there doing it for free and they're not doing it because they want to give up 26 weekends of their life for your kid. So you got to weigh all those things and you know and appreciate the fact that you have a really good coach dad, mom, the babysitter, whatever just have a good coach and have somebody that values your children. And the only other thing I would say, too, is just be approachable. You know, just don't shield yourself off if you're going to coach your kid longer than the little youth hockey world. You know you just got to probably in my opinion, in my judgment and experience, just kind of open yourself up a little bit.
38:17 You almost have to open yourself a little bit more to be like listen, have a conversation with me, because I don't want you critiquing me behind my back, because when you do that your kid's hear it and then that affects my kid, like because I'm you know. So all of a sudden your kid gets kind of he gets you know, kind of not blackballed, but kind of like isolated in that situation. So it's always you know. So I think it goes both ways for a parent coach, that's coaching your kid into a level of you know, not just the little you know, the little kids. Yeah, like I'll say this parents, all of us, including you and myself we don't control the team typically, but we do influence it by what you say to your kids after a game or the lessons you give them.
39:02 Again, we talk a lot about the accountability level, of not blaming but understanding the situation you're in and learning to grow past it. Parents, you play a major role, you're all coaches at the end of the day, in that regard, you're all coaches to our kids. But yeah, mike, I think. Again, just some actionable items. You know, if you are a parent coach, really no matter the age, but as you get older, you should be leaning on this more Definitely, have a conversation with the parents before the year. Have a conversation with your own kid before the year. First off, make sure they understand the expectations of you as a coach and as a parent, and then talk to the parents, let them know yeah, my kids on the team. This is the rules that we have decided that everyone's gonna adhere to, including my child. If you have any questions or any problems, don't commiserate.
39:45 Please come up to me and talk to me, and then you gotta be true to your word. I mean, like I've met a lot of yes people in my life that say one thing and do another. Unfortunately, that's the reality of the world. That's not just youth hockey, right, but high levels of integrity. If you find someone with a high level integrity, the knowledge you know, communication skills, trust, I mean, I don't care if they're a parent or not at the end of the day, at that point that's a good person to have on your bench right. And again, look if you can get the money and get a highly qualified coach, it's gonna do a great job. That's great too. At the end of the day, it's one of those episodes there's not gonna be a concrete answer. It just it depends, depends on the age, depends on the level, depends on the location, depends on experience.
40:27 I also wanna tell this story, too, that great coaches typically are great coaches. There's a story about Vince Lombardi, who was one of the greatest football coaches of all time, coaching a basketball team to a championship. Having never played the game, he's just a great coach, right. So it's not limited to just your knowledge of the game of hockey, right? I mean, hopefully you have some of that, but it comes down to, just like I said, integrity, the type of person that you are. I think that being a parent adds a little spice onto that equation. But it's not the meat, right? It's not the chicken or the poultry, the fish or tofu.
41:08 If you're vegan, I'm trying to include everybody here, but you understand. But, mike, that was all the comments. This was a little great episode here. It was a great topic, just like the comments section a lot of discussion, a lot of different points of view. For those of you listening obviously want to know what you think when you see this poster. You're listening. Read us an email at teamadricatesplayhockeycom. Feel free to put a comment on our Facebook page. Again, I know not everybody's high on Facebook, but they do do a good job with the group stuff. You can find us, Adricates Playhockey, on the groups. Again, you have to answer a couple yes or no questions to get in, but the conversations we have really continue on there and that's growing all the time. So if you're looking for other like-minded parents around the world because we do have listeners around the world it's a great place to go.
41:50 Mike, before I close this out, I want to let you know if you have any other final thoughts on this. No, I think you summed it up. It's all the circumstances you're in and it's a case-by-case basis most of the time. More times than not, as the kids get older, you'd love to see them. That's why people go away to school, right, and for instance, like on my situation, I don't coach my own son at high school level. Season starts and he's got his own coach. I help with the bake sale and do chaka-paka, I guess, and do the things that the other parents do. But the bottom line is it's all the circumstances you're in and then what the needs are. And if you can fill the needs and help with some circumstances, great.
42:33 If you don't need to and you can step back, I don't know. Even better, I guess, Just gauge it and then be fair and be open and responsible to discussions, and I think it solves a lot of other issues, just like everything else we talk about. Just a little communication always makes things easier. Always comes back to communication, and I want to close this out by communicating to all of you another big thank you. So in the last month, in the month of August, which is not traditionally a hockey month had our best day, our best week and our best month ever in terms of listeners of this program. So we want to thank all of you for doing that. Remind you, as this is the season now we're in the season when you're listening to this please share this with the other parents.
43:15 Please share this with your organizations, not just for our behalf, but because we know this conversation is happening in rinks around the United States and the world and we want to be a conduit for those conversations. Not about us, right? It's about all of us listening and making sure that we can continue to grow that community. So again, if you have, if you're inclined, share this episode, share the page at kidplayhockeycom and remember all of the episodes will be here this entire season. We're going to be here with this. Who ride to the rink and our kids play goalie here on our Kids Play Hockey. Have a wonderful week, everybody. Take care. We hope you enjoyed this edition of Our Kids Play Hockey. Make sure to like and subscribe right now if you found value.
43:56 Wherever you're listening, whether it's a podcast network, a social media network or our website, ourkidsplayhockeycom. Also, make sure to check out our children's book when Hockey Stops at whenhockeystopscom. It's a book that helps children deal with adversity in the game and in life. We're very proud of it. But thanks so much for listening to this edition of Our Kids Play Hockey and we'll see you on the next episode.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeartRadio
Amazon Music
RSS Feed